Shop Favorites

Ready to Ship

All items in this collection are ready to ship as is. They... 

Spring is the season for baseball and golf!

Get your little sports fan ready for all the fun this season brings!

Customer Reviews

  • Sample Shirt Club

    “We just got our first order! The shirt is beautifully made and came beautifully and thoughtfully wrapped. So excited to order again for gifts and our little guy.” - C.D.

    Sample Shirt Club Subscription 
  • 10/10 Recommend

    "Product was amazing and so carefully packaged with love!" - M.T.

    Keepsake Card Holder 
  • LOVE!

    “This ornament could not be more perfect and I know my family will cherish it forever! The perfect keepsake for our first Christmas as a family of four!” - L.C.

    Family Christmas Ornament 
  • 10/10 Quality

    “The best quality and customer service. These shirts are so well made and I love feeling like my son is in something special. Thank you!! Shop local” - L.A.

    Crossed Baseball Bats on Home Plate 

Quick Links

Contact Us

Thank you for checking us out!

Subtly Southern is a husband and wife owned small shop specializing in embroidery and engraving. We love to make things personal and we can’t wait to help you create something that’s perfectly personalized for you!

The fastest and easiest way to contact us is by sending us a message below. You may also contact us via email at

Our business hours are Monday through Friday 9am - 5pm Eastern. Please allow up to 48 hours to receive a response. 

Thank you!


**At this time, we are not accepting personal items (not purchased from our website).**

Monogram Options

Please see our monogram font and thread color options below. 

When selecting a monogram font, please consider the monogram formats listed below. Also, please submit your desired monogram name or initial in the exact order you wish to have them embroidered/engraved. 
Please note: Monogram size depends on item size. We will try to embroider the largest possible monogram unless otherwise specified.


**At this time, we are not accepting personal items (not purchased from our website).**

Thank you!


All Things New Sketch (Sketch Fill) 

Benjamin (Sketch Fill) 


Block Shadow (Satin Fill) 

Bonnie Bean 

Bouncy Block Serif 

Bubbly Satin (2-Color, Satin Fill) 

Camp Notes (2-Color, Sketch Fill) 

Cedarwood (2-Color) 



Classic Circle


Color Ribbon


Copycat (Satin Fill)


Croquet Bay

Cupcake Party 

Curly Girl Serif (2-Color)

Curly Q

Cursive Floss

David Floss


Dino Spikes (2-Color, Sketch Fill)

Dotted Stringy Splinter (2-Color)


Eskimo Kiss Batty

Eskimo Kiss Stars

Eskimo Kisses

Eyes Wide Open

Fishtail (Satin Fill)

Florence Floss (Sketch Fill)


Frisky Jam Bean

Frisky Jam Satin (Satin Fill)

Georgia Classic

Girly Goose (Satin Fill)

Good Vibes

Graceful (Satin Fill)

Hand Printed

Hodgepodgery Floss


Interlocking Vine

Interlocking Vine Floss




Love Rawr

Maggie Scribble

Master Circle


Night Owl (2-Color, Satin Fill)


Oink Owl

Oscar Scribble

Sawyer Bay

Scalloped (2-Color, Sketch Fill)

Scooter Sketch (2-Color, Sketch Fill)

September Floss


Seven Sixteen (2-Color)


Sherman Vintage

Smell the Roses

So Jelly (2-Color, Sketch Fill)

Spooky Bones

Spring Candy Sketch (Sketch Fill)


Studmuffin (Sketch Fill)


Sweet Pea

Tall Serif Satin Bean (2-Color, Satin Fill)

Trenton Presley

Vintage Olivia

Walk Away (Sketch Font)

Watermelon (Satin Fill)

Watermelon Margarita Sketch (Sketch Fill)


William Double (2-Color)



PLEASE NOTE: When ordering an item with personalized monogramming, 

please choose both a font option and a thread color (see choices above).

Shipping Info

PLEASE NOTE: Our current turnaround time for personalized items is 10-14 business days. We will complete your item(s) and ship your order as soon as we possibly can. Thank you!

Expedited shipping is not available at this time.

We will contact you if there are any issues with your order. Thank you for your understanding.


Return Policy

All customized products from Subtly Southern are final sale due to the personalized nature of monogrammed items. 


Please inspect your order immediately upon arrival. If you receive a damaged or defective item, you must contact us within 48 hours of delivery.


If our returns department receives the merchandise within 14 days of delivery, a refund will be issued to the original form of payment. Due to credit card processing fees, there will be a 10% restocking fee on all cash refunds. There will be no restocking fee if you choose to accept store credit.


If our returns department receives your return past the 14th day of delivery or the return does not meet the guidelines as outlined in our return policy, the items will be shipped back to the address provided on your original order. A standard shipping charge will be applied to the credit card used for the initial purchase.


Please note that shipping charges are non-refundable. You can send your package back to us using the shipping method of your choice, as you are responsible for these shipping charges as well. We suggest using a shipping service with tracking capabilities or purchasing insurance for the package. We are not responsible for any packages lost or damaged in the mail and will not issue any refunds for them.


Exchanges: Because merchandise is available in limited quantities, we are unable to offer any exchanges. We suggest placing a new order for any items you want and following our return policy as outlined above.

Information Sharing

Your rights under the California Consumer Privacy Act

The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) provides you with rights regarding how your data or personal information is treated. Under the legislation, California residents can choose to opt out of the “sale” of their personal information to third parties. Based on the CCPA definition, “sale” refers to data collection for the purpose of creating advertising and other communications. Learn more about CCPA and your privacy rights.

How to opt out

By clicking on the link below, we will no longer collect or sell your personal information. This applies to both third-parties and the data we collect to help personalize your experience on our website or through other communications. For more information, view our privacy policy.